There's an annual music festival for women held in Michigan called, appropriately, the
Michigan Womyn's Music Festival. I'm not going to go into its history; I trust that you're all capable of reading the
Wikipedia article. "Michfest", known as a feminist event, is designated a "
womyn-born-womyn space". Which means that if you were born with a Y chromosome, you can't set foot on the land. Literally.
Yes, well, that's all well and good, and certainly we want women (I'm going to stick with the misogynistic, patriarchal spelling) to have spaces just for themselves. But are you telling me that I can't bring my girlfriend, who has spent her life knowing she's a girl, and is actively working toward being recognized by society as one, to a festival designed to make me--born XX, with all the appropriate parts, keeping those parts, and even loving people with those parts--feel warm and cozy?
This is a deeply flawed facet of feminism. It started out for at least semi-well-off heterosexual white women. Then someone noticed that there were other colors, and I guess they had to be included, and oh wow, those are women, and they like other women, and gosh, those women are poor, but they're still women. Feminism, as any good feminist will tell you, hasn't overcome these (hopefully unintentional and subconscious) prejudices. But I think that trans acceptance is even more behind.
Skin color, who you love, and socioeconomic status are a lot different than chromosomes and genitalia. I think that in many ways a black gay rich woman has more in common with a white straight poor woman than she does with a black gay rich man. Being raised a woman, being raised with the fear of men (not all men, obviously, but that guy walking down the street alone at 9pm? definitely him), with the millennia of virtually universal oppression, with the knowledge that no matter how progressive your family might be, out in the real world you're still making 80 cents on the dollar--being raised with those things is huge, and something that I don't know that any transgender woman can every really understand.
Look, to say that a transgender woman can't attend the workshop on childhood sexual trauma, I get. There are multiple workshops, in fact, where I could see it justified. Most things relating to childhood. A lot of things relating to sex, especially sexual violence. I don't want to make anyone cry. But I think that Michfest, and other places with WBW policies, are missing the point. I think that they are relying on their own prejudices, their own gut feelings, to make choices that impact real live women.
It can be hard to overcome the instinct to say, "You're going to cut WHAT off?!" Certainly while we're all hopefully being told that color doesn't matter and class doesn't matter, and many of us told that sexual orientation doesn't, I don't really see many people growing up being told about transgender people. The media doesn't help. Even LGBT rights organizations often ignore the T's (see: HRC on ENDA. Oh come on, Wiki it yourself).
It will take a long time for people to get over those prejudices, and to accept trans people,
MTF and
FTM. And as with race, class, and all of the other "other" issues feminism has had to confront,
realizing that there's an issue doesn't fix it. We're still navigating that, figuring out how to work with women of color, and lesbians, and disabled women needing separate spaces and with women as a whole needing to join.
Feminism isn't perfect. We have a long way to go. I have a long way to go, you have a long way to go, we have a long way to go. But exclusion does not, historically, go well. Would I ever have gone to Michfest? Probably not, no, I don't like it outside, I'm Feminist in PINK, not...whatever you wear outside. But I certainly won't consider it until they end the WBW policy [which my brief research (read: Googling) indicated they may have, but reinstated it, or not, it's all very unclear, feel free to clarify in the comments]. And I won't be giving money to any organization with that policy. And more importantly, I, and many many other feminists, am finding myself having to reject other feminists, and that is not, cannot be conducive to The Movement.
This process, the process of acknowledgement, acceptance, and change, is going to take a while. I'm not a terribly patient person, but I recognize that this is going to take a while, and that for now I can speak up, make my case, and then go cuddle with my girlfriend.